Following Donald Trump’s victory in the 2024 US presidential election, financial advisers are becoming more optimistic about the regulatory environment for major deals.
With the new administration indicating an eased stance toward mergers and acquisitions in financial services, one of the most significant pending transactions is Capital One's proposed $35.3 billion takeover of Discover Financial Services. If approved, this deal could reshape the US credit card industry and leave a lasting impact on the financial landscape. Announced in February 2024, the merger between Capital One and Discover Financial Services is set to be one of the largest in U.S. banking history, ranking as the fifth-largest transaction of its type. Capital One, based in Virginia, reported $1.8 billion in net income for the third quarter of 2024, while Illinois-based Discover reported a net income of $965 million for the same period.
If the deal moves forward, the combined company will become the largest credit card issuer in the US, with over 305 million cardholders and $250 billion in outstanding loans. With the predicted market share of the combined companies exceeding 30%, the merger would solidify Capital One's position at the forefront of the credit card industry while expanding its payment operations.
Despite optimism about regulatory approvals under the new administration, the deal still faces scrutiny. The New York Attorney General, Letitia James, is investigating whether the merger would violate antitrust laws, citing potential impacts on the New York market where both companies have a significant presence. Capital One holds over $9.5 billion in credit card loans in New York, while Discover accounts for $6.5 billion, raising concerns about reduced competition which could have major implications for customers with lower credit scores.
Moreover, both companies are dealing with legal challenges from customers, who sued in July 2024 alleging that the merger could drive up costs and limit the options available to consumers. These challenges highlight the difficulty in obtaining approvals from shareholders, regulators, the Department of Justice, and the Federal Trade Commission.
Following Trump’s election win, the stock market responded favourably to the prospect of the merger. Capital One’s share price rose by 13%, while Discover saw a 17% jump. Analysts attribute these gains to expectations that the new administration will accelerate deal-making processes, including regulatory reviews. If approved, the merger is expected to close by early 2025.
While the deal promises significant benefits for the combined company, its impact on customers remains uncertain. Capital One plans to maintain Discover-branded credit cards but has not disclosed plans for Discover’s other banking products. Notably, Discover offers several unique products, such as a Cashback Debit Checking Account, which could be discontinued in favour of Capital One's 360 Checking account.
Discover’s range of Certificates of Deposit and money market accounts could add to Capital One’s products, expanding customer choice. However, concerns about customer service quality persist. Discover is highly rated for its 24/7 US-based customer service team, a feature Capital One currently lacks. While there is potential for Capital One to keep Discover’s service team to enhance customer experience, no official decision has been announced yet.
Despite concerns from regulators and consumers, the merger could bring significant changes to the financial services industry. The combined entity would have a greater capacity to innovate and expand product offerings, potentially driving growth. However, the full impact on customers, particularly in terms of service quality and product availability, remains unclear until the deal is finalised. In the broader context, the proposed merger highlights the evolving dynamics of the US financial sector, where consolidation is increasingly seen as a pathway to competitiveness. Whether this move ultimately benefits consumers will depend on how the merged entity balances growth while maintaining quality and affordability.
Comments